Smooth Like Butter

9 products
Sort by
Sort by
Hand holding a package of salted butter stress toy with a wooden shelf in the background Hand squishing a salted butter stress toy in front of shelves with similar products.
Slow Rise Butter Squishy
$12.99
Stick of Butter Lighter - Novelty Food | Friends Nyc Stick of Butter Lighter - Novelty Food | Friends Nyc
Stick of Butter Lighter
$7.99
WOMEN OWNED
Butter Dad Hat - Yellow Cotton Cap | Friends Nyc Brooklyn Ny Butter Dad Hat - Yellow Cotton Cap | Friends Nyc Brooklyn Ny
Butter Dad Hat
$34.99
Small Stick of Butter Ornament Glass | Funny Holiday Small Stick Of Butter Ornament Butter - Food Ornament -
Small Stick of Butter Ornament
$16.99
Butter Hair Claw - Ceramic Food Novelty Accessory | Friends Butter Hair Claw - Ceramic Food Novelty Accessory | Friends
Butter Hair Claw
$19.99
Butter Heart Sticker Butter - Decorative Sticker - Fake Butter Heart Sticker Butter - Decorative Sticker - Fake
Butter Heart Sticker
$4.99
Toast Stoneware Shaped Plate | Friends Nyc Brooklyn Ny Toast Stoneware Shaped Plate | Friends Nyc Brooklyn Ny
Toast Stoneware Shaped Plate
$19.99
NEW
Slow Rise Jumbo Butter Squishy 9’’ - Fun Doh Sensory Toy Slow Rise Jumbo Butter Squishy 9’’ - Fun Doh Sensory Toy
Slow Rise Jumbo Butter Squishy
$19.99
NEWSold out
Melty Butter Cube Squishy Toy by Grabie | Friends Nyc Melty Butter Cube Squishy Toy by Grabie | Friends Nyc
TELL ME WHEN IN STOCK 🔔
Melty Butter Cube Squishy
$14.99

Spread the fun with our collection of butter-themed novelties and gifts! From playful butter-shaped collectibles to clever butter-inspired accessories, this curated selection celebrates everyone's favorite dairy staple in the most unexpected ways. Perfect for food lovers, collectors, and anyone who appreciates a good pun, these unique items add a touch of whimsy to everyday life.