White Elephant - Gifts Under $20

Browse By
687 products
Sort by
Sort by
Eyeballs Gift Bag - Small All Over Print Birthday Cat Lover Eyeballs Gift Bag - Small All Over Print Birthday Cat Lover
Eyeballs Gift Bag 9.5"
$7.99
Small Gift Bag Bgs Groovy Mushrooms Per2376bgs Gift Bag - Small Gift Bag Bgs Groovy Mushrooms Per2376bgs Gift Bag -
Groovy Mushrooms Gift Bag 9.5"
$7.99
Cottagecore Cross-stitch Kit Activity - Book - Activity
Cottagecore Cross-Stitch Kit
$10.95
EXCLUSIVE
Hand Silkscreen Postcard - Crazy for you Cat Cat Hand Silkscreen Postcard - Crazy for you Cat Cat
Hand Silkscreen Postcard - Crazy For You Cat
$4.99
WOMEN OWNED
Miró Women’s Crew Socks | Friends Nyc Brooklyn Miró Women’s Crew Socks Abstract - Art - Crew Socks
Miró Women's Crew Socks
$14.99
LGBTQ+ OWNED
Frog and Toad Sticker Decorative Sticker - Made in the Usa Frog and Toad Sticker Decorative Sticker - Made in the Usa
Frog and Toad Sticker
$5.99
Tiny Pencils Set 1122 - Colored Pencils - Grabngo2022 - Tiny Pencils Set 1122 - Colored Pencils - Grabngo2022 -
Tiny Colored Pencils Tube Set
$9.99
LGBTQ+ OWNEDSave 80%
Labubu Eat me Die Cut Sticker - Kawaii Vinyl | Friends Nyc Labubu Eat me Die Cut Sticker - Kawaii Vinyl | Friends Nyc
Labubu Eat Me Die Cut Sticker
$1.00 $4.99
Another Year of Growth Greeting Card A2 - Birthday Card
Another Year of Growth Greeting Card
$6.99
EXCLUSIVE
Friends Nyc x Pil Collab Card the Stars Aligned C3342 Friends Nyc x Pil Collab Card the Stars Aligned C3342
The Stars Aligned Card
$6.99
WOMEN OWNED
Trash can Raccoon Decorative Sticker - Drawn Goods - Funny
Trash Can Birthday Raccoon Sticker
$4.99
Purple Cabbage Coin Purse | Friends Nyc Brooklyn Ny Purple Cabbage Coin Purse | Friends Nyc Brooklyn Ny
Purple Cabbage Coin Purse
$16.99
WOMEN OWNED
Hottie Hot Dog Birthday Greeting Card A2 - Birthday Card Hottie Hot Dog Birthday Greeting Card A2 - Birthday Card
Hottie Hot Dog Birthday Greeting Card
$6.99
Greetings From New York Card Greeting - i <3 Nyc Gifts Greetings From New York Card Greeting - i <3 Nyc Gifts
Greetings From New York Card
$6.99
WOMEN OWNED
Risograph Greeting Card Yow Lucky Ever Groupbycolor - Vday23 Risograph Greeting Card Yow Lucky Ever Groupbycolor - Vday23
Fortune Cats Greeting Card
$6.99
Standard Baggu Reusable Tote i Love Ny Accessory Bag Baggu Standard Baggu Reusable Tote - i Love Ny - Iconic Nyc
Standard Baggu Reusable Tote - I Love NY
$14.99
Siamese Cat Birthday Card A2 - Blank - Card - Greeting
Siamese Cat Birthday Card
$6.99
Palm Pals Plush Toy - Juicy Strawberry Fake Food Palm Pals Plush Toy - Juicy Strawberry Fake Food
Palm Pals Plush Toy - Juicy Strawberry
$12.99
EXCLUSIVESave 75%
Friends Nyc Daddy Heart Sticker Decorative Sticker Friends Nyc Daddy Heart Sticker Decorative Sticker
Friends NYC Daddy Heart Sticker
$1.00 $3.99
Toy figure of a Kirby on top of a yellow star-shaped watch with a digital display on a green background Kirby Digital Watch Blind Box | Friends Nyc Brooklyn
Kirby Digital Watch Blind Box
$12.99
LGBTQ+ OWNED
Gay Love Valentine’s Day Greeting Card Greeting Card - Lgbtq Gay Love Valentine’s Day Greeting Card Greeting Card - Lgbtq
Gay Love Greeting Card
$6.99
EXCLUSIVESave 25%
Friends Nyc Cunty Mug | Brooklyn Ny Friends Nyc Cunty Mug | Brooklyn Ny
Friends NYC Cunty Mug
$15.00 $19.99
Japanese Restaurant Animals Blind Box Japan - Made Japanese Restaurant Animals Blind Box Japan - Made
Japanese Restaurant Animals Blind Box
$12.99
Marlin Rodeo Congratulations Greeting Card A2 - Blank Marlin Rodeo Congratulations Greeting Card A2 - Blank
Marlin Rodeo Congratulations Greeting Card
$6.99

Explore our handpicked collection of gifts priced between $10 and $20 - the sweet spot for meaningful presents that fit any budget. Perfect for:

  • Birthday gifts and special occasions
  • Hostess gifts and thank you presents
  • Secret Santa and office gift exchanges
  • Treating yourself without the guilt

Every item in this collection offers exceptional value and style. Whether you're shopping for friends, family, or coworkers, you'll find thoughtful gifts that look and feel more expensive than they are. Browse our selection and discover affordable luxury!