White Elephant - Gifts Under $20

Browse By
687 products
Sort by
Sort by
We’re In This Together Sardines Encouragement Greeting We’re In This Together Sardines Encouragement Greeting
We're in this Together Sardines Encouragement Greeting Card
$6.99
EXCLUSIVESave 62%
Friends Nyc Bic Lighter - Emotional Support Printed Friends Nyc Bic Lighter - Emotional Support Printed
Friends NYC Bic Lighter - Emotional Support
$3.00 $7.99
WOMEN OWNED
Twilight Matches - Vampire Romance Novel Matchbook Twilight Matches - Vampire Romance Novel Matchbook
Twilight Matches
$16.99
Save 70%
Yaya Little Naughty Bag Blind Box - Kawaii Charm | Friends Yaya Little Naughty Bag Blind Box - Kawaii Charm | Friends
Yaya Little Naughty Bag Blind Box
$3.00 $9.99
The Little Frog’s Guide to Life: Love Advice
The Little Frog's Guide to Life: Love, Advice and Inspiration Book
$11.99
WOMEN OWNED
Dilly Dally Pickle Greeting Card A2 - Blank - Card - Cards
Dilly Dally Pickle Greeting Card
$6.99
You’re the Shit - Shrimp Pop-up Greeting Card Greeting Card You’re the Shit - Shrimp Pop-up Greeting Card Greeting Card
You're The Shit Shrimp Pop-Up Greeting Card
$6.99
Martini Glass with Olive Fake Food - Kitchen and Drink Martini Glass with Olive Fake Food - Kitchen and Drink
Martini Glass With Olive
$19.99
Mini Colored Pencils w Sharpener Art Supplies - Colored Mini Colored Pencils w Sharpener Art Supplies - Colored
Mini Colored Pencils w Sharpener
$7.99
WOMEN OWNED
Sensitive Ghost Die Cut Vinyl Sticker Decorative Sticker Sensitive Ghost Die Cut Vinyl Sticker Decorative Sticker
Sensitive Ghost Die Cut Vinyl Sticker
$4.99
Panda Glass Pipe Asst Ph188 Hand Pipe Smoke Shop Smoking Panda Glass Pipe Asst Ph188 Hand Pipe Smoke Shop Smoking
Panda Glass Hand Pipe
$19.99
Toad Birthday Greeting Card Birthday - Card - Birthdays
Toad Birthday Greeting Card
$6.99
EXCLUSIVE
Friends Nyc x Pil Collab Card Ilysm Bestie C3343 Exclusive Friends Nyc x Pil Collab Card Ilysm Bestie C3343 Exclusive
ILYSM Bestie Card
$6.99
A Tiny Sex Diary a Tiny Diary - Journal - Journaling - Mini A Tiny Sex Diary a Tiny Diary - Journal - Journaling - Mini
A Tiny Sex Diary
$8.99
Brooklyn Mug 0922 - Nycstories - Q322 - Wendybuild Brooklyn Mug 0922 - Nycstories - Q322 - Wendybuild
Brooklyn Souvenir Mug
$16.99
Lorelai Gilmore i Love Hot Moms Lighter - Girls Pop Culture Lighter with a design featuring a heart and text on a blue background. Text says "I love hot moms"
Lorelai Gilmore I Love Hot Moms Lighter
$7.99
LGBTQ+ OWNED
Sticker of a flaming dumpster with 'Everything's Fine' text held against a pink background Sticker of a flaming green dumpster with 'Everything's Fine' text on a pink background with disco balls.
Dumpster Fire Everything's Fine Sticker
$5.99
Astro Cats Blind Box Box - Cat - Toy - Xpsd0725a Astro Cats Blind Box Box - Cat - Toy - Xpsd0725a
Astro Cats Blind Box
$19.99
Hem Black Opium Incense Sticks Black Opium - Floral Black Opium Incense Sticks Black Opium - Floral - Handmade
Black Opium Incense Sticks
$2.99
Forest Blue Gift Bag - Small Birthday Gifts - Forest - Gift Forest Blue Gift Bag - Small Bff Gifts - Gift Bag - Bags
Forest Blue Gift Bag 7"
$6.99
LGBTQ+ OWNED
The found Greeting Card Bitch 1128 Artistmade - Groupbycolor The found Greeting Card Bitch 1128 Artistmade - Groupbycolor
Britney B!tch Birthday Greeting Card
$5.99
Pink rhinestone ashtray on a pink background Silver ashtray with pink rhinestone trim on a pink background
Bling Ashtray - Pink
$19.99
Dr Pepper Tic Tac Mints 1.7oz | Friends Nyc Brooklyn Ny Dr Pepper Tic Tac Mints 1.7oz | Friends Nyc Brooklyn Ny
Dr Pepper Tic Tac
$6.99
LGBTQ+ OWNED
Brooklyn Pigeon Sticker Die Cut the Found | Friends Nyc Ny Brooklyn Pigeon Sticker Die Cut the Found | Friends Nyc Ny
Brooklyn Pigeon Sticker
$4.99

Explore our handpicked collection of gifts priced between $10 and $20 - the sweet spot for meaningful presents that fit any budget. Perfect for:

  • Birthday gifts and special occasions
  • Hostess gifts and thank you presents
  • Secret Santa and office gift exchanges
  • Treating yourself without the guilt

Every item in this collection offers exceptional value and style. Whether you're shopping for friends, family, or coworkers, you'll find thoughtful gifts that look and feel more expensive than they are. Browse our selection and discover affordable luxury!