White Elephant - Gifts Under $20

Browse By
687 products
Sort by
Sort by
NEW
Decorate a Christmas Tree with 40 Stickers Reusable Sticker Decorate a Christmas Tree with 40 Stickers Reusable Sticker
Decorate a Christmas Tree With 40 Stickers
$6.99
NEW
Holiday Tin - Living Room Persimmon & Chestnut Candle Holiday Tin - Living Room Persimmon & Chestnut Candle
Holiday Tin Candle - Living Room Persimmon & Chestnut
$19.99
LGBTQ+ OWNED
Die Cut Sticker - Zohran Mamdaddy Mamdani Mam Daddy Die Cut Sticker - Zohran Mamdaddy Mamdani Mam Daddy
Die Cut Sticker - Zohran Mamdaddy
$4.99
LGBTQ+ OWNED
Ash + Chess Holiday Card Wishing Warmth 0922 - Groupbycolor Wishing you Warmth Holiday Card A2 - Acab - Ash + Chess
Wishing You Warmth Holiday Card
$6.99
Cosrx Advanced Snail Mucin Power Sheet Mask Beauty - Cosrx Cosrx Advanced Snail Mucin Power Sheet Mask Beauty - Cosrx
COSRX Advanced Snail Mucin Power Sheet Mask
$5.99
LGBTQ+ OWNED
Howlidays Holiday Card Animal Lover - Novelty - Ash + Chess Howlidays Holiday Card Animal Lover - Novelty - Ash + Chess
Happy Howlidays Holiday Card
$6.99
WOMEN OWNED
Merry Bright Cat Holiday Card Cat - Card - Dad Gifts - Lover Merry Bright Cat Holiday Card Cat - Card - Dad Gifts - Lover
Merry Bright Cat Holiday Card
$6.99
WOMEN OWNED
Apotheke Charcoal Votive Candle Apotheke - Artist Made - Apotheke Charcoal Votive Candle Apotheke - Artist Made -
Apotheke Charcoal Votive Candle
$19.99
WOMEN OWNED
Ping Hatta Sticker - Tarot Cat The Hermit 0822 - Bff Gifts Ping Hatta Sticker - Tarot Cat The Hermit 0822 - Bff Gifts
Ping Hatta Sticker - Tarot Cat The Hermit
$4.99
WOMEN OWNED
Ping Hatta Holiday Card Hanukka Groupbycolor - Hanukkah Fat Cat Holiday Card Cat - Card - Dad Gifts - Lover
Hanukkah Fat Cat Holiday Card
$6.99
Olive Wine Stopper Fake Food - Kitchen and Drink - Olive Olive Wine Stopper Fake Food - Kitchen and Drink - Olive
Olive Bottle Stopper
$14.99
WOMEN OWNED
Toy Holiday Card A2 - Blank - Card - Christmas
Toy Stocking Holiday Card
$7.99
Save 37%
A chibi-style anime figurine of a girl with brown hair and green eyes, wearing a red and white dress with heart details and a gold crown, holding a golden wand with white wings, standing on a peach-colored surface against a light blue background. A pink and white PalVerse collectible card box featuring an anime-style character illustration, photographed on a peach and light blue gradient background.
Palverse Cardcaptor Sakura Blind Box
$15.00 $23.99
Save 40%
A Hello Kitty plush keychain styled as a strawberry character, wearing a pink strawberry costume with a green leaf collar and a pink flower hair accessory, sitting on a peach-colored surface against a blue background. A pink product box for 'TOP TOY Santio characters Sweet Strawberry' blind box set, featuring cute strawberry-themed cartoon characters on the front, set against a split blue and pink background.
Sanrio Family Sweet Strawberry Plush Keychain Blind Box
$15.00 $24.99
Food Keychain - Shrimp Dad - Food Novelty - Funny Keychain Food Keychain - Shrimp - Plain | Novelty at Friends Nyc
Food Keychain - Shrimp
$9.99
Pomegranate Bag Charm Red | Friends Nyc Brooklyn Ny Pomegranate Bag Charm Red | Friends Nyc Brooklyn Ny
Pomegranate Bag Charm
$14.99
Food Keychain - Shrimp Food Novelty - Funny Keychain - Food Keychain - Shrimp Food Novelty - Funny Keychain -
Food Keychain - Shrimp with Eyes
$9.99
Food Keychain - Lemon Slice Accessory - Food Novelty - Funny Food Keychain - Lemon Slice Accessory - Food Novelty - Funny
Food Keychain - Lemon Slice
$9.99
LGBTQ+ OWNED
Cartoon of two hockey players facing each other with text 'Turn up the heat, it's your birthday' on a pink background Motivational quote 'Time to Celebrate' on a white background with a pink border
Heated Rivalry The Heat is On Birthday Card
$6.99
EXCLUSIVE
Friends x Maptote Bushwick Mug 1022 - Q422 - Q4ecomm22 Friends x Maptote Bushwick Mug 1022 - Q422 - Q4ecomm22
Friends NYC x Maptote Bushwick Mug
$19.99
This is Fine Talking Figurine Comic - Gag Gift This is Fine Talking Figurine Comic - Gag Gift
This is Fine Talking Figurine
$14.99
EXCLUSIVE
Friends Nyc Cunty Socks - Unisex Cunty - Cute Socks Friends Nyc Cunty Socks - Unisex Cunty - Cute Socks
Friends NYC Cunty Socks - Unisex
$14.99
EXCLUSIVE
Friends Nyc x Pf Ny Kush Santal Candle Exclusive Candle Friends Nyc x Pf Ny Kush Santal Candle Exclusive Candle
Friends NYC x P.F. Candle Co - Kush Santal Candle Exclusive
$19.99
New York City Rat Christmas Greeting Card Nyc with Santa
New York City Rat Christmas Greeting Card
$6.99

Explore our handpicked collection of gifts priced between $10 and $20 - the sweet spot for meaningful presents that fit any budget. Perfect for:

  • Birthday gifts and special occasions
  • Hostess gifts and thank you presents
  • Secret Santa and office gift exchanges
  • Treating yourself without the guilt

Every item in this collection offers exceptional value and style. Whether you're shopping for friends, family, or coworkers, you'll find thoughtful gifts that look and feel more expensive than they are. Browse our selection and discover affordable luxury!