White Elephant - Gifts Under $20

Browse By
693 products
Sort by
Sort by
Save 74%
Zoraa Cuteness is Justice Blind Box | Friends Nyc Brooklyn Zoraa Cuteness is Justice Blind Box | Friends Nyc Brooklyn
Zoraa Cuteness is Justice Blind Box
$7.00 $26.99
Save 67%
A hand with pink nail polish holds a lit BIC Realtree lighter against a blurred store background. A hand with pink nail polish holds a BIC Realtree lighter with a dark gray and black camouflage pattern, lit and showing a flame, in front of a blurred retail display.
Bic Realtree Hunter Series Lighter - Assorted
$2.00 $5.99
Save 74%
A hand holds a colorful product box labeled 'Puppy Farmer' with a cartoon red puppy character on the front, photographed in a blurred store or shop interior background. Puppy Farmer Blind Box | Friends Nyc Brooklyn Ny
Puppy Farmer Blind Box
$5.00 $18.99
Save 60%
Let’s Put it on Top Fluffy Seals Blind Box | Friends Nyc Let’s Put it on Top Fluffy Seals Blind Box | Friends Nyc
Let's Put it on Top Fluffy Seals Blind Box
$4.00 $9.99
NEW
Vibrant Snakes Gift Bag Large 12.75’’ Medium - Red Cap
Vibrant Snakes Gift Bag Large 12.75"
$7.99
NEW
Cat & Bakes Bakery Bread Blind Box | Friends Nyc Brooklyn Ny Cat & Bakes Bakery Bread Blind Box | Friends Nyc Brooklyn Ny
CAT & BAKES Cat Bakery Bread Blind Box
$12.99
NEW
Mofusand Fluffy Pajama Figure Blind Box - Nyanpantsu Mofusand Fluffy Pajama Figure Blind Box - Nyanpantsu
Mofusand Fluffy Pajama Figure Blind Box
$12.99
NEW
Eat it Pussy! Candy Novelty 3oz | Friends Nyc Brooklyn Ny Eat it Pussy! Candy Novelty 3oz | Friends Nyc Brooklyn Ny
Eat It Pussy! Candy
$3.99
NEW
Cat Litter Snow Globe Blind Box | Friends Nyc Brooklyn Ny Cat Litter Snow Globe Blind Box | Friends Nyc Brooklyn Ny
Cat Litter Snow Globe Blind Box
$12.99
NEW
Flocked Cats in Paper Bags Blind Box - 6 Designs | Friends Flocked Cats in Paper Bags Blind Box - 6 Designs | Friends
Flocked Cats in Paper Bags Blind Box
$9.99
NEW
No Worries Vinyl Sticker Matte - Deadpan Humor | Friends
No Worries Vinyl Sticker
$4.99
NEW
Fuuuuuuck Socks Funny Crew - Novelty Gift | Friends Nyc
Fuuuuuuck Socks
$14.99
NEW
Kermit Figurine Singing the Frog - Muppets Collectible Kermit Figurine Singing the Frog - Muppets Collectible
Kermit Figurine Singing
$16.95
NEW
Slow Rise Jumbo Butter Squishy 9’’ - Fun Doh Sensory Toy Slow Rise Jumbo Butter Squishy 9’’ - Fun Doh Sensory Toy
Slow Rise Jumbo Butter Squishy
$19.99
NEW
Super Duper Squishers Jellyfish - Assorted Squishy Toy Super Duper Squishers Jellyfish - Assorted Squishy Toy
Super Duper Squishers Jellyfish - Assorted
$9.99
NEW
Super Duper Sugar Squisher Mushroom Assorted Squishy Toy Super Duper Sugar Squisher Mushroom Assorted Squishy Toy
Super Duper Sugar Squisher Mushroom Assorted
$9.99
NEW
Gold Stars Small Gift Bag 6’’ by Sunshine Studios | Friends Gold Stars Small Gift Bag 6’’ by Sunshine Studios | Friends
Gold Stars Small Gift Bag 6"
$8.99
NEW
Butts on Things Wall Calendar 2027 | Friends Nyc Brooklyn Ny March - Chocolate bunny with a butt
Butts on Things Wall Calendar 2027
$17.99
NEW
A 2027 Mr. Men and Little Miss calendar cover featuring the brand title at the top and a group of colorful cartoon characters clustered in the center. A single hanging desk calendar page featuring the Little Miss character. The top section has a pink border and shows the text 'LITTLE MISS SWEETHEART' above a cartoon illustration of the character.
Mr. Men Little Miss Wall Calendar 2027
$8.99
NEW
A 2027 Jeopardy! calendar box shown at an angle against a solid dark blue background. The box is black with a subtle grid pattern and features the word 'JEOPARDY!' in large white letters, with 'JEOPARDY! CHAMPIONS' in yellow and 'JEOPARDY! CHAMPIONS' in pink accents. Jeopardy! game show card with question, answer, and branding
Jeopardy! Day-To-Day Calendar 2027
$17.99
NEW
The New York Times Cooking Page-a-day® Calendar 2027 Nyt A New York Times Cooking article page titled 'Butter Paneer' with recipe text, a photo of a plated paneer dish, and a red footer bar with the date.
The New York Times Cooking Page-A-Day® Calendar 2027
$19.99
NEW
The New York Times Crossword Page-a-day® Calendar 2027 Nyt A New York Times Games crossword puzzle page for Tuesday, January 5, 2027, with a black-and-white grid and clues printed in two columns on a white background.
The New York Times Crossword Page-A-Day® Calendar 2027
$19.99
NEW
The Sopranos 2027 wall calendar box, an HBO Original page-a-day calendar, shown at a three-quarter angle against a solid red background. A square graphic design for a script card or poster print, featuring a white center with dialogue text between Little Carmine and Tony, set against a dark red border and a gray background.
The Official Sopranos Page-A-Day® Calendar 2027
$17.99
LGBTQ+ OWNEDSave 40%
Ash and Chess Sticker - Silly Cat Vinyl | Friends Nyc Ash and Chess Sticker - Silly Cat Vinyl | Friends Nyc
Ash and Chess Sticker - Silly Cat
$3.00 $4.99

Explore our handpicked collection of gifts priced between $10 and $20 - the sweet spot for meaningful presents that fit any budget. Perfect for:

  • Birthday gifts and special occasions
  • Hostess gifts and thank you presents
  • Secret Santa and office gift exchanges
  • Treating yourself without the guilt

Every item in this collection offers exceptional value and style. Whether you're shopping for friends, family, or coworkers, you'll find thoughtful gifts that look and feel more expensive than they are. Browse our selection and discover affordable luxury!